Thursday, August 28, 2008

The Great Gatsby

  • Blog – Nick says in this chapter that Gatsby’s “count of enchanted objects had diminished by one”.  What is he referring to?  How has Gatsby lost it?

 

When Nick says, “count of enchanted objects had diminished by one’ he means that Gatsby is basically showing off by objects and has forgotten the true meaning in which they all got together with Daisy for “tea”. Gatsby in this chapter, while seeing Daisy again for the first time in like 10 years or something, is showing off his personal possessions instead of trying to show Daisy how he still really feels about her.  Gatsby is only hiding behind these possessions because he is shy and possibly very easily broken by what Daisy could say to him.

But as we find out later in the chapter that Gatsby, during his time just watching Daisy secretly, has formed up a imaginary Daisy that in no way can compare to the real one.  And that’s where the part of the quote, “diminished by one”, means. It just seems like Gatsby is being greedy and over imaginative about the women he loves. This in turn means that Daisy will never live up to what Gatsby now wants of her.



Blog – Nick tells us the truth about Gatsby in this chapter.  Speculate why Gatsby makes up the lie, and why Nick decides to tell us at this point in the book as opposed to earlier.

 

In the book Nick tells us that Gatsby or John Gats is really some guy who basically was poor and was never always rich. Nick and partially Gatsby, John Gats, tell us that Before Gatsby was shipped out he was a poor seven-teen year old boy who had just met someone that would basically give him everything he’d ever need, Dan Cody.

The effect it took on Gatsby was great; it was so great that John Gats was no longer called well John Gats but would not be called Gatsby.

After spending his time then with Dan Cody and receiving a generous amount of money… then loosing it to his first wife, Gatsby joined the army and server in the war. While serving in the war he earned medals and such, and after the war he received the option to go to Oxford. On his return from Oxford and such Gatsby then wanted to rekindle the relationship between him and Daisy but had found out that Daisy was married and his hopes were dashed.

 

So when Nick was telling us about Gatsby’s past he really wasn’t lying, he just told the partial truth. But why he decided to do that is awkward and very mysterious because now it seems like Nick also maybe hiding something that he is refusing to tell us. Or maybe he’s just giving us the info only when we “need” to know it.



  • Blog – This chapter and chapter 7 are the climax of the novel.  Explain how something mentioned earlier might have hinted at these climatic events.

  

Earlier in the book I feel like there were a few points where that action in the book basically set the demise for someone. Like when Jordan and Nick first met. I felt like when Nick told us that since he met Jordan and no one else had come along and she was basically his only choice; it kind of felt like Nick was being really selfish or he just said whatever. And as it turned out that Nick’s overall mind set about Jordan and him being together was wrong.

Another example could be when Myrtle’s nose was broken by Tom. I mean you could say that when Myrtle went home and Wilson could have thought something like, “ Dang, she must have pissed off her sister”, or , “What has she really been doing?”. It’s one of those kinds of events that could have been a realization for Wilson or it could have just been another day an a life for him.

Finally I also feel like Daisy and Gatsby trying to rekindle a lost love only spelt trouble for later on in the book. This is because Daisy is already married and Gatsby has a far fetched vision of Daisy now. And Daisy just can’t life up to what Gatsby wants her to be now. This small event then turned into a big ordeal when everyone, Tom, Jordan, Daisy, Nick, and Gatsby because Gatsby and Tom basically get into a big argument. And the only result for this argument is pain for Gatsby, Tom, and Daisy. 




  • Blog – React to the attendance at Gatsby’s funeral.  Why do the people who come, come? What is it meant to show us?

 

Gatsby’s Funeral really didn’t surprise me because after all that has happened in the book I didn’t really think anyone he knew other then Nick, Owl Eyes, and his Henry C. Gatz would really show up. I mean Henry C. Gatz was Gatsby’s father and Nick was just a friend what not to really understand about those two coming. And then Daisy and Tom not coming wasn’t surprising because Daisy was probably still in shock from killing Myrtle and Tom probably just didn’t want to go cause he disliked Gatsby and didn’t want Daisy to go for the same reason. Then there was also Jordan, but she didn’t come because she claimed to have gotten a new boy friend and they were getting married soon and she had no time. Which was a total lie but I didn’t really see Jordan caring about Gatsby enough and she probably just didn’t want to see Nick either.

 

But to really answer the question I only see that Nick and Gatsby’s Father comes because it’s like they need to because they were closer to Gatsby then anyone else. And it’s really meant to show us that Tom and Daisy never liked Gatsby at all, even Daisy even though she claimed she was in love with him. And that they were just straight up greedy people.

It was also meant to show us that Nick, even though it seems like through the book he may have been lying to us, really did feel close to Gatsby. I mean at the end of the chapter, after the funeral, Nick goes back to Gatsby’s house and finds some graphite and gets rid of it. It kind of showed really how much Nick cares, even though he was a lying little… person. 

1 comment:

Anonymous said...

These blogs are mostly well done, but this is your warning. Do them all on Thursday again, and I won't count them.